Beyond day one: Setting new hires up for success

7

minute read

No items found.
Allison Harllee

Allison Harllee

HR Manager

aharllee@raftelis.com
Evie O'Donnell

Evie O'Donnell

HR Associate

eodonnell@raftelis.com

Do you remember your first day at a new job? Waiting on system access, trying to learn everyone's name, all while hoping you made the right decision by joining the organization. Starting at a new company can feel like a whirlwind, but it also gives employers an opportunity to make that transition as smooth as possible.

At a glance

  • Onboarding works best as a process that runs through an employee's first year. Orientation covers paperwork and introductions, but new hires may take 12 months to reach full performance.
  • Regular HR check-ins at 30, 60, and 90 days, six months, and one year helps organizations spot onboarding gaps early and improve the process over time.
  • Managers have an outsized effect on the experience. New hires are 3.4 times likely to rate their onboarding as exceptional when their manager takes an active role.

Onboarding is often seen as a one-day or one-week endeavor. The new hire sits through an orientation, fills out some paperwork, and is left to figure out the rest on their own. When support ends that early, new employees can take longer to get up to speed, feel disconnected from their team, and begin to question whether the organization was the right fit. Gallup research shows how common this is. Only 12% of employees strongly agree that their organization does a great job onboarding new employees.

At Raftelis, we have found that onboarding should be a process, not a single event. We consider the new hire period to extend through an employee's entire first year. Below, we share practices that have helped us support new employees throughout that first year, for organizations and for managers, along with advice for those starting a new role themselves.

Orientation and onboarding are not the same thing

The two blend into one another, but they serve different purposes. Orientation is the welcome. It covers paperwork, benefits, policies, equipment, and introductions, usually in the first day or week. Onboarding is the longer process of helping someone understand their role, build relationships, and become a confident contributor. Orientation tells a new hire where things are. Onboarding helps them understand how the organization works and where they fit in.

Why onboarding matters

Onboarding gives new hires a firsthand look at how smoothly the organization operates and how it treats its people. Those early weeks set the tone for an employee's entire tenure, and one of the most effective ways to build momentum is through intentional connection. Insight Global's 2025 Employee Sentiment Report found that four in five workers would stay longer in a role with a better onboarding process. Gallup also estimates that new employees typically take around 12 months to reach their full performance potential, which is why one week of support falls short.

Best practices for the organization

To set an employee up for success, the organization needs a clear plan. Who owns the different phases of onboarding? What systems and equipment will new hires need? SOPs should be current and easy to find for all core tasks, and each onboarding meeting should be assigned to the right owner, whether HR, IT, or the manager.

Build in regular HR check-ins, such as at 30, 60, and 90 days, six months, and one year. These conversations show how the employee is feeling, uncover gaps in their onboarding, and help refine the process. Useful questions include:

  • "Do you feel like you have a clear picture of what success looks like in your role?"
  • "How do you feel about the training and onboarding you have received? Is there anything you wish you'd learned sooner or want more of?"
  • "How integrated do you feel into the team and the broader company culture?"
  • "Do you have everything you need to be successful, including tools, resources, information, and support?"

Surveys on training sessions and onboarding resources add value because they can offer anonymity, which can make new hires more candid. Keep new hire feedback in mind regarding their onboarding and training so you can find new ways to improve and fill in gaps as your team and organization evolve. Peer connection matters too. A formal buddy system gives new hires someone to turn to with questions they may not want to bring to their manager.  

Best practices for managers

Before day one

All system accounts and equipment should be configured before your employee arrives. If they will work in an office, communicate arrival times, parking, and entry directions, and have their workspace ready. Let your team know a new team member is starting and set the expectation that everyone is a resource ready to support them.

The first week

Structure week one so it does not overwhelm your new employee while still giving them the key tools they need. Schedule a meet-and-greet, office tour, team lunch (or a virtual alternative for remote staff), and onboarding meetings in advance. Make sure your new hire knows who to contact on other teams with questions. This gives them context on who does what and an early start on cross-functional relationships.

The first month

Show the new hire what is expected of them. Assign projects they can begin working on immediately, and explain the "why" behind what the organization does, not only the "how." Discuss what success looks like in their position and set goals with clear expectations. HR leaders surveyed by Enboarder in 2025 ranked clear role expectations as the top factor in successful onboarding, and they named a mismatch between job expectations and reality as the leading reason new hires leave. A weekly touchpoint helps you catch issues early.

Beyond the first month

Reinforce goals with regular feedback, both positive and constructive. As the new hire grows more comfortable, delegate meaningful responsibilities so they can learn by doing while building trust and autonomy. Make it comfortable for them to ask questions and even make some mistakes. Answering questions and correcting errors takes extra effort up front, but it saves time in the long run. Gallup found that new hires are 3.4 times as likely to rate their onboarding as exceptional when their manager takes an active role. Approach the learning curve with patience, and remember that you were new once, too.

Making the most of your own onboarding

Even with the best-designed process, new employees play a part in their own onboarding. Asking questions early and often is not only common but expected. Ask your manager what success looks like if you are unsure, ask for feedback instead of waiting for it, and reach out to teammates with day-to-day questions. Build relationships within and beyond your immediate team to broaden your support system. As you settle in, share your observations about onboarding, daily tasks, or team workflows in one-on-ones or HR check-ins. Colleagues can find it helpful to hear from someone with fresh eyes.

Moving forward

The new hire experience is a pivotal time that sets the tone for an employee's tenure. Getting it right requires preparation, connection, two-way feedback, and patience. Treating onboarding as a process rather than a single event results in more informed, confident, and productive employees who make meaningful contributions early on, both to the organization and to the communities we serve.