Helping North Carolina face the real cost of regional water infrastructure

6

minute read

Chad Cowan

Chad Cowan

Senior Manager

ccowan@raftelis.com

Some infrastructure problems can be solved with a better plan. Others require something harder: an honest accounting of what the problem actually costs, who can bear it, and who cannot. For 38 utilities spread across seven counties in central North Carolina, Raftelis was asked to provide exactly that.

A corridor under pressure

The Study Area runs along US Highway 421 between I-85 in Greensboro and I-95 in Dunn, spanning Guilford, Randolph, Chatham, Lee, Harnett, Johnston, and Southern Wake counties, including the communities of Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina. The region was previously designated a high-priority corridor under the federal Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021, showing both its growth potential and the scale of its infrastructure needs.

The tension in this corridor is familiar to many rural regions: household growth and commercial investment are arriving, but the smaller utilities serving these communities were already struggling before growth accelerated the pressure. Rising capacity needs and operating costs are outpacing revenue, leaving local governments with an uncomfortable choice between raising rates on already financially stressed populations or deferring the maintenance their systems need. Many have deferred. The result is aging, at-risk infrastructure that will require significant reinvestment before any regional solution can even be contemplated.

The NC Department of Environmental Quality engaged Raftelis in January 2024 to bring financial clarity to this picture across all 38 utilities in the Study Area.

A scorecard built for honest comparison

With 38 utilities of vastly different sizes, financial conditions, and service profiles, the study needed a framework that could hold them all. Raftelis developed a Utility Strength Scorecard using nine key metrics incorporating individual utility system characteristics, financial metrics, and affordability criteria. Built from publicly available data, the scorecard gave decision-makers a consistent, comparable snapshot of where each utility stood and where the greatest vulnerabilities were concentrated.

The total capital investment required across the Study Area exceeds $10.17 billion, a figure that would necessitate significant state and federal funding, with no guarantee it would materialize. Affordability is already a widespread challenge across the region, with the most severe conditions in the smaller utilities and the eastern counties of Harnett and Johnston. For utilities serving populations under 10,000, the prospect of taking on additional debt for regionalization infrastructure could critically worsen affordability without meaningful outside support.

The study also surfaced a structural reality that any regional solution would have to reckon with: the utilities in this corridor are not uniformly positioned. Variations in utility strength and geographic disparities mean a one-size-fits-all regional approach would not produce equitable outcomes. Designing for the average would leave the most vulnerable communities worse off.

What the study positions the region to do

The Utility Strength Scorecard is a starting point, not a final answer. The study explicitly states that a more thorough, in-depth review of each utility's financials, system condition, capital improvement plans, and recent debt issuances would be necessary before any specific regionalization effort moves forward. What the study provides is the foundational context that makes those next conversations possible: a shared, data-grounded understanding of where the pressure points are and what regional solutions would realistically require.

Done well, regionalization in this corridor could deliver real benefits: spreading fixed infrastructure and administrative costs across a larger customer base, improving financial health and rate affordability, and enabling utilities to maintain and upgrade systems they could not sustain independently. The study's findings make clear that achieving those benefits will depend on strategic design, meaningful state and federal support, and a willingness to account honestly for what smaller communities can and cannot absorb.

For state agencies and regional planners navigating similar terrain, the NC DEQ study offers a replicable model: use financial analysis not to build the case for a predetermined solution, but to understand the landscape clearly enough to find the right one.

For more information, contact us.

Chad Cowan

Chad Cowan

Senior Manager

ccowan@raftelis.com